writers.net
 
Home Writers Literary Agents Editors Publishers Resources Discussion WritersNet Email  
  Log in  |  Join WritersNet

Writers Net Discussion Forum

 

Critique newbie

Author: Carl Purdon (---.static.networktel.net)
Date:   07-10-08 09:12

I've only been here for a few weeks and I posted my first critique of someone else's work a day or so ago. It was more difficult than I had imagined but the real surprise was how much it helped me look at my own work.

My critique skills suck, mind you, and I realize that. I aim to improve with practice. There's something about the process, though, that opens my eyes to my own flaws.

Is this true for the ones of you who always have such good suggestions?

 

Re: Critique newbie

Author: Wonky (192.250.49.---)
Date:   07-10-08 21:29

Of course.

 

Re: Critique newbie

Author: Patrick Edwards (63.240.53.---)
Date:   07-11-08 10:01

Absolutely, Carl :)

That's why sometimes it's almost best to run through other's postings and praise/critique those and pull everything you can from them (including what others mention in their responses). Even if you don't consciously do it, it's seeping into your subconscious. Kinda creepy (sounds like brainwashing! :), but....)

 

Re: Critique newbie

Author: Kitty Foyle (---.dsl.scrm01.sbcglobal.net)
Date:   07-11-08 10:15

Off the subject (sorry 'bout that), but has anybody noticed how often "absolutely" is used these days? Especially in those TV interviews.

Absolutely!

*_*

 

Re: Critique newbie

Author: Ray Veen (---.sb.trinity-health.org)
Date:   07-11-08 20:11

I like to lurk over in writing craft before I do any editing - if I can guess what the pros are gonna say, then I'm ready to dig into my own writing.



Sorry. You need to Join WritersNet and activate your account to post a message.
It's quick, easy and free. All we need is a valid email address and the name you wish to use here .
Home | Writers | Literary Agents | Editors | Publishers | Resources | Discussion | Newsletter | My writers.net


©1994-2008 Netconcepts, LLC.   Legal Notice    About Us   Advertise   Contact Us   Privacy Policy