writers.net
 
Home Writers Literary Agents Editors Publishers Resources Discussion WritersNet Email  
 

Writers Net Discussion Forum


Re: Query Critique, please.

Author: Ray Spengler

dream,

I may not be one to offer effective critisism, but I love the query. The hook is effective in my view and the body left me wanting to read the thing. Now, the genre isn't my thing but your query almost works.

Chelsea had (has) perished.
Leave off 'that horrific night'.
mysteriosly holds - maybe change to providing.
Completely and overwhelmingly - drop it.

I can only say that you whet the reader's appetite. Unfortunately, the agent should require more. Is Aiden's disappearance to be a tragic event? What does Elsie need to happen? What will transpire if he disappears? The goal is clear but the reason isn't - the result of failure.

Otherwise, I'm impressed. Keep working at it.

IMHO.

Ray

Topics Author Date
 Query Critique, please.  new
dream catcher 11-01-09 22:32 
 Re: Query Critique, please.  new
Ray Spengler 11-02-09 00:28 
 Re: Query Critique, please.  new
dream catcher 11-02-09 01:13 
 Re: Query Critique, please.  new
Jason Coggeshall 11-02-09 13:28 
 Re: Query Critique, please.  new
Cindy Kay 11-02-09 15:25 
 Re: Query Critique, please.  new
dream catcher 11-03-09 09:52 
 Re: Query Critique, please.  new
Chris Hagler 11-03-09 18:44 


Sorry. You need to Join WritersNet and activate your account to post a message.
It's quick, easy and free. All we need is a valid email address and the name you wish to use here .